Table 1

Study

Period

Species

Location

Number Sampled

Pollutant

Pollutant source

% Poisoned/ Contaminated

Reference

1970

Mute Swan + Pochard

Denmark

10

DDE

Pesticide

   0*

Bloch and Kraul, 1972

1975-1979

Mute Swan

Denmark

552

Lead

Lead pellets

11

Anderson-Harild, 1982

1969-1975

Mute Swan

England, Ouse Washes

52

Lead

Fishing weights and shot

4

Owen and Cadbury, 1975

1973

Mute Swan

England, Nottingham

29

Lead

Fishing weights

62

Simpson et al., 1979

1975-1978

Mute Swan

England, Nottingham

66

Lead

 -

56

Hardman and Cooper, 1980

1980-1981

Mute Swan

England, various

11

Lead

 -

73

NCC, 1981

1979

Mute swan

England, Thames

94

Lead

Fishing weights

57

Birkhead, 1982

1981-1982

Mute swan

England, various rivers

320

Lead

Shot

70

French, 1982

1984

Mute swan

England, various

600

Lead

 -

78

French, 1984

1979-1982

Mute swan

England, Thames Valley

89

Lead

Fishing weights

64

Birkhead and Perrins, 1985

1981-1985

Mute Swan

England, East Anglia

627

Lead

Fishing weights and shot

74

Birkhead and Perrins, 1986

1981-1985

Mute Swan

England, various

666

Lead

 -

48

Birkhead and Perrins, 1986

1983-1986

Mute swan

England, Thames

166

Lead

Pellets

40

Sears, 1988

1983-1986

Mute swan

England, Thames

518

Lead

Fishing weights

61

Sears et al., 1989

1951-1989

Mute Swan

England, various

193

Lead

 -

23

Brown et al., 1992

2000-2002

Mute swan

England, Midlands

1,491

Fishing Line/Hooks

Discarded Tackle

17

Kelly and Kelly, 2004

2000-2003

Mute swan

England, Midlands

1,491

Lead

 -

74

Kelly and Kelly, 2004

1984-1986

Mute swan

Ireland

357

Lead

Fishing weights and shot

44

O'Halloran et al., 1988a

1984-1986

Mute swan

Ireland

101

Lead

Fishing weights and shot

68

O'Halloran et al., 1988c

1975-1989

Mute Swan

Netherlands

227

Lead

Fishing weights and shot

1

Esselink and Beekman, 1991

1989

Mute swan

Japan

9

Copper

 -

89

Kobavashi et al., 1992

1994-1997

Mute swan

Japan, various

93

Lead

 -

34

Ochiai et al., 1999

1981-1985

Mute Swan

Scotland, various

18

Lead

 -

33

Birkhead and Perrins, 1986

1980-1984

Mute swan

Scotland

70

Lead

 -

13

MacDonald et al., 1987

1980-1986

Mute swan

Scotland

149

Lead

Fishing weights and shot

13

Spray and Milne, 1988

1973-1977

Mute Swan

Sweden

58

Lead

 -

19

Frank and Borg, 1979

1973-1977

Mute swan

Sweden

58

Cadmium

Sediment

0**

Frank and Borg, 1979

1995

Mute swan

USA, Anacostia River

17

PAHs

River sediment

52

Beyer et al., 2000a + b

1988

Mute swan

Wales

13

Oil

Milford Haven oil spill

23

Quick, 1993

1969-1975

Whooper swan

England, Ouse washes

5

Lead

Shot

20

Owen and Cadbury, 1975

1979-1981

Whooper swan

England, various

5

Lead

Shot

20

Mudge, 1983

1951-1989

Whooper swan

England, various

23

Lead

 -

35

Brown et al., 1992

1981-1986

Whooper swan

Scotland, Northeast

33

Lead

Shot

58

Spray and Milne, 1988

1981-1986

Whooper swan

Scotland, various

24

Lead

 -

33

Spray and Milne, 1988

1984-1987

Whooper swan

Ireland, Cork

4

Lead

Shot

100

O'Halloran et al., 1988c

1973-1977

Whooper swan

Sweden

4

Lead

 -

25

Frank and Borg, 1979

1984-1987

Whooper swan

Japan

17

Lead

Shot

29

Honda et al., 1990

1989

Whooper swan

Japan

15

Lead

Shot

100

Ochiai et al., 1992

1969-1975

Bewick swan

England, Ouse Washes

25

Lead

Fishing weights and shot

28

Owen and Cadbury, 1975

1979-1981

Bewick swan

England, various

20

Lead

Shot

20

Mudge, 1983

1951-1989

Bewick swan

England, various

150

Lead

 -

13

Brown et al., 1992

1984-1987

Bewick swan

Japan

8

Lead

Shot

25

Honda, 1990

1976-1987

Trumpeter swan

USA, 7 states

72

Lead

Fishing weights and shot

25

Blus et al., 1989

1985

Trumpeter swan

USA, Idaho

4

Lead

Mining

75

Kreiger, 1990

1986-1989

Trumpeter swan

USA, Minnesota

116

Lead

Shot

46

Degernes and Frank, 1991

1986-1992

Trumpeter + Tundra swan

USA, Washington

136

Lead

Shot

35

Lagerquist et al., 1994

1989

Trumpeter swan

Canada, B. C.

24

Lead

Shot

38

Langelier et al., 1989

1992

Trumpeter swan

Canada, B. C.

15

Lead

Shot

100

Bowes, 1992

1976-1994

Trumpeter swan

Canada, B. C.

186

Lead

Shot

47

Wilson et al., 1998

1964

Tundra swan

USA, Wisconsin

200

Lead

Shot

32

Trainer and Hunt, 1965a + b

1987-1990

Tundra swan

USA, Idaho

43

Lead

Shot and Mining

79

Blus et al., 1991

1981-1988

Tundra swans

USA, 9 states

171

Lead

 -

29

Bartonek et al., 1991

1987-1997

Tundra swan

USA, Idaho

19

Lead

Mining

94

Blus et al., 1999

1972

Tundra swans

Canada, Ontario

31

Lead

Shot

65

Irwin, 1975

1985

Black swan

Australia, south

5

Lead

Shot

100

Koh and Harper, 1988

 *   Contamination low in all specimens and no effect on eggshell thickness observed

 ** All specimens were contaminated with cadmium but none were found to have signs of any harmful effects.

 

Table 1. Studies of Pollution Contamination Responses in Swans. The species of swan, the location and the number of swans studied are shown. The pollutant being examined, its source and the proportion of specimens contaminated/poisoned by the pollutant are also shown. Studies where no response to the contamination was documented, or where the proportion of birds affected was not recorded, have been omitted.