Table 1
|
Study Period |
Species
|
Location
|
Number Sampled |
Pollutant
|
Pollutant source |
% Poisoned/
Contaminated |
Reference |
|
1970 |
Mute Swan + Pochard |
|
10 |
DDE |
Pesticide |
0* |
Bloch and Kraul, 1972 |
|
1975-1979 |
Mute Swan |
|
552 |
Lead |
Lead pellets |
11 |
Anderson-Harild, 1982 |
|
1969-1975 |
Mute Swan |
|
52 |
Lead |
Fishing weights and shot |
4 |
Owen and Cadbury, 1975 |
|
1973 |
Mute Swan |
|
29 |
Lead |
Fishing weights |
62 |
Simpson et al., 1979 |
|
1975-1978 |
Mute Swan |
|
66 |
Lead |
- |
56 |
Hardman and Cooper, 1980 |
|
1980-1981 |
Mute Swan |
|
11 |
Lead |
- |
73 |
NCC, 1981 |
|
1979 |
Mute swan |
|
94 |
Lead |
Fishing weights |
57 |
Birkhead, 1982 |
|
1981-1982 |
Mute swan |
|
320 |
Lead |
Shot |
70 |
French, 1982 |
|
1984 |
Mute swan |
|
600 |
Lead |
- |
78 |
French, 1984 |
|
1979-1982 |
Mute swan |
|
89 |
Lead |
Fishing weights |
64 |
Birkhead and Perrins, 1985 |
|
1981-1985 |
Mute Swan |
|
627 |
Lead |
Fishing weights and shot |
74 |
Birkhead and Perrins, 1986 |
|
1981-1985 |
Mute Swan |
|
666 |
Lead |
- |
48 |
Birkhead and Perrins, 1986 |
|
1983-1986 |
Mute swan |
|
166 |
Lead |
Pellets |
40 |
Sears, 1988 |
|
1983-1986 |
Mute swan |
|
518 |
Lead |
Fishing weights |
61 |
Sears et al., 1989 |
|
1951-1989 |
Mute Swan |
|
193 |
Lead |
- |
23 |
Brown et al., 1992 |
|
2000-2002 |
Mute swan |
|
1,491 |
Fishing Line/Hooks |
Discarded Tackle |
17 |
Kelly and Kelly, 2004 |
|
2000-2003 |
Mute swan |
|
1,491 |
Lead |
- |
74 |
Kelly and Kelly, 2004 |
|
1984-1986 |
Mute swan |
|
357 |
Lead |
Fishing weights and shot |
44 |
O'Halloran et al., 1988a |
|
1984-1986 |
Mute swan |
|
101 |
Lead |
Fishing weights and shot |
68 |
O'Halloran et al., 1988c |
|
1975-1989 |
Mute Swan |
|
227 |
Lead |
Fishing weights and shot |
1 |
Esselink and Beekman, 1991 |
|
1989 |
Mute swan |
|
9 |
Copper |
- |
89 |
Kobavashi et al., 1992 |
|
1994-1997 |
Mute swan |
|
93 |
Lead |
- |
34 |
Ochiai et al., 1999 |
|
1981-1985 |
Mute Swan |
|
18 |
Lead |
- |
33 |
Birkhead and Perrins, 1986 |
|
1980-1984 |
Mute swan |
|
70 |
Lead |
- |
13 |
MacDonald et al., 1987 |
|
1980-1986 |
Mute swan |
|
149 |
Lead |
Fishing weights and shot |
13 |
Spray and Milne, 1988 |
|
1973-1977 |
Mute Swan |
|
58 |
Lead |
- |
19 |
Frank and Borg, 1979 |
|
1973-1977 |
Mute swan |
|
58 |
Cadmium |
Sediment |
0** |
Frank and Borg, 1979 |
|
1995 |
Mute swan |
|
17 |
PAHs |
River sediment |
52 |
Beyer et al., 2000a + b |
|
1988 |
Mute swan |
|
13 |
Oil |
Milford Haven oil spill |
23 |
Quick, 1993 |
|
1969-1975 |
Whooper swan |
|
5 |
Lead |
Shot |
20 |
Owen and Cadbury, 1975 |
|
1979-1981 |
Whooper swan |
|
5 |
Lead |
Shot |
20 |
Mudge, 1983 |
|
1951-1989 |
Whooper swan |
|
23 |
Lead |
- |
35 |
Brown et al., 1992 |
|
1981-1986 |
Whooper swan |
|
33 |
Lead |
Shot |
58 |
Spray and Milne, 1988 |
|
1981-1986 |
Whooper swan |
|
24 |
Lead |
- |
33 |
Spray and Milne, 1988 |
|
1984-1987 |
Whooper swan |
|
4 |
Lead |
Shot |
100 |
O'Halloran et al., 1988c |
|
1973-1977 |
Whooper swan |
|
4 |
Lead |
- |
25 |
Frank and Borg, 1979 |
|
1984-1987 |
Whooper swan |
|
17 |
Lead |
Shot |
29 |
Honda et al., 1990 |
|
1989 |
Whooper swan |
|
15 |
Lead |
Shot |
100 |
Ochiai et al., 1992 |
|
1969-1975 |
Bewick swan |
|
25 |
Lead |
Fishing weights and shot |
28 |
Owen and Cadbury, 1975 |
|
1979-1981 |
Bewick swan |
|
20 |
Lead |
Shot |
20 |
Mudge, 1983 |
|
1951-1989 |
Bewick swan |
|
150 |
Lead |
- |
13 |
Brown et al., 1992 |
|
1984-1987 |
Bewick swan |
|
8 |
Lead |
Shot |
25 |
Honda, 1990 |
|
1976-1987 |
Trumpeter swan |
|
72 |
Lead |
Fishing weights and shot |
25 |
Blus et al., 1989 |
|
1985 |
Trumpeter swan |
|
4 |
Lead |
Mining |
75 |
Kreiger, 1990 |
|
1986-1989 |
Trumpeter swan |
|
116 |
Lead |
Shot |
46 |
Degernes and Frank, 1991 |
|
1986-1992 |
Trumpeter + Tundra swan |
|
136 |
Lead |
Shot |
35 |
Lagerquist et al., 1994 |
|
1989 |
Trumpeter swan |
Canada, B. C. |
24 |
Lead |
Shot |
38 |
Langelier et al., 1989 |
|
1992 |
Trumpeter swan |
Canada, B. C. |
15 |
Lead |
Shot |
100 |
Bowes, 1992 |
|
1976-1994 |
Trumpeter swan |
Canada, B. C. |
186 |
Lead |
Shot |
47 |
Wilson et al., 1998 |
|
1964 |
Tundra swan |
|
200 |
Lead |
Shot |
32 |
Trainer and Hunt, 1965a + b |
|
1987-1990 |
Tundra swan |
|
43 |
Lead |
Shot and Mining |
79 |
Blus et al., 1991 |
|
1981-1988 |
Tundra swans |
|
171 |
Lead |
- |
29 |
Bartonek et al., 1991 |
|
1987-1997 |
Tundra swan |
|
19 |
Lead |
Mining |
94 |
Blus et al., 1999 |
|
1972 |
Tundra swans |
|
31 |
Lead |
Shot |
65 |
Irwin, 1975 |
|
1985 |
Black swan |
|
5 |
Lead |
Shot |
100 |
Koh and Harper, 1988 |
|
* Contamination low in all specimens and no effect on
eggshell thickness observed ** All specimens were contaminated
with cadmium but none were found to have signs of any harmful effects. |
|||||||
Table 1. Studies of Pollution Contamination
Responses in Swans. The species of swan, the location and the
number of swans studied are shown. The pollutant being examined, its source and
the proportion of specimens contaminated/poisoned by the pollutant are also
shown. Studies where no response to the contamination was documented, or where
the proportion of birds affected was not recorded, have been omitted.